# Optimization with OpenModelica¶

The following facilities for model-based optimization are provided with OpenModelica:

- Builtin Dynamic Optimization with OpenModelica and IpOpt using
- dynamic optimization is the recommended way of performing dynamic optimization with OpenModelica.

- Dynamic Optimization with OpenModelica and CasADi. Use this if you want to employ
- the CasADi tool for dynamic optimization.

- Classical Parameter Sweep Optimization using OMOptim. Use
- this if you have a static optimization problem.

## Builtin Dynamic Optimization with OpenModelica and IpOpt¶

*Note: this is a very short preliminary decription which soon will be
considerably improved.*

OpenModelica provides builtin dynamic optimization of models by using the powerful symbolic machinery of the OpenModelica compiler for more efficient and automatic solution of dynamic optimization problems.

The builtin dynamic optimization allows users to define optimal control problems (OCP) using the Modelica language for the model and the optimization language extension called Optimica (currently partially supported) for the optimization part of the problem. This is used to solve the underlying dynamic optimization model formulation using collocation methods, using a single execution instead of multiple simulations as in the parameter-sweep optimization described in section Parameter Sweep Optimization using OMOptim.

For more detailed information regarding background and methods, see [BOR+12][RBB+14]

## Compiling the Modelica code¶

Before starting the optimization the model should be symbolically instantiated by the compiler in order to get a single flat system of equations. The model variables should also be scalarized. The compiler frontend performs this, including syntax checking, semantics and type checking, simplification and constant evaluation etc. are applied. Then the complete flattened model can be used for initialization, simulation and last but not least for model-based dynamic optimization.

The OpenModelica command optimize(ModelName) from OMShell, OMNotebook or MDT runs immediately the optimization. The generated result file can be read in and visualized with OMEdit or within OMNotebook.

## An Example¶

In this section, a simple optimal control problem will be solved. When formulating the optimization problems, models are expressed in the Modelica language and optimization specifications. The optimization language specification allows users to formulate dynamic optimization problems to be solved by a numerical algorithm. It includes several constructs including a new specialized class optimization, a constraint section, startTime, finalTime etc. See the optimal control problem for batch reactor model below.

Create a new file named BatchReactor.mo and save it in you working directory. Notice that this model contains both the dynamic system to be optimized and the optimization specification.

Once we have formulated the undelying optimal control problems, we can run the optimization by using OMShell, OMNotebook, MDT, OMEdit using command line terminals similar to the options described below:

```
>>> setCommandLineOptions("-g=Optimica");
```

```
model BatchReactor
Real x1(start =1, fixed=true, min=0, max=1);
Real x2(start =0, fixed=true, min=0, max=1);
input Real u(min=0, max=5);
equation
der(x1) = -(u+u^2/2)*x1;
der(x2) = u*x1;
end BatchReactor;
```

```
optimization nmpcBatchReactor(objective=-x2)
extends BatchReactor;
end nmpcBatchReactor;
```

```
>>> optimize(nmpcBatchReactor, numberOfIntervals=16, stopTime=1, tolerance=1e-8)
record SimulationResult
resultFile = "«DOCHOME»/nmpcBatchReactor_res.mat",
simulationOptions = "startTime = 0.0, stopTime = 1.0, numberOfIntervals = 16, tolerance = 1e-08, method = 'optimization', fileNamePrefix = 'nmpcBatchReactor', options = '', outputFormat = 'mat', variableFilter = '.*', cflags = '', simflags = ''",
messages = "LOG_SUCCESS | info | The initialization finished successfully without homotopy method.
Optimizer Variables
========================================================
State[0]:x1(start = 1, nominal = 1, min = 0, max = 1, init = 1)
State[1]:x2(start = 0, nominal = 1, min = 0, max = 1, init = 0)
Input[2]:u(start = 0, nominal = 5, min = 0, max = 5)
--------------------------------------------------------
number of nonlinear constraints: 0
========================================================
******************************************************************************
This program contains Ipopt, a library for large-scale nonlinear optimization.
Ipopt is released as open source code under the Eclipse Public License (EPL).
For more information visit http://projects.coin-or.org/Ipopt
******************************************************************************
LOG_SUCCESS | info | The simulation finished successfully.
",
timeFrontend = 0.090752839,
timeBackend = 0.039145082,
timeSimCode = 0.028770168,
timeTemplates = 0.006275334,
timeCompile = 0.3292402059999999,
timeSimulation = 0.027337657,
timeTotal = 0.521633937
end SimulationResult;
```

The control and state trajectories of the optimization results:

## Different Options for the Optimizer IPOPT¶

numberOfIntervals | collocation intervals | |

startTime, stopTime | time horizon | |

tolerance = 1e-8 | e.g. 1e-8 | solver tolerance |

simflags | all run/debug options |

-lv | LOG_IPOPT | console output |

-ipopt_hesse | CONST,BFGS,NUM | hessian approximation |

-ipopt_max_iter | number e.g. 10 | maximal number of iteration for ipopt |

externalInput.csv | input guess |

## Dynamic Optimization with OpenModelica and CasADi¶

OpenModelica coupling with CasADi supports dynamic optimization of models by OpenModelica exporting the optimization problem to CasADi which performs the optimization. In order to convey the dynamic system model information between Modelica and CasADi, we use an XML-based model exchange format for differential-algebraic equations (DAE). OpenModelica supports export of models written in Modelica and the Optimization language extension using this XML format, while CasADi supports import of models represented in this format. This allows users to define optimal control problems (OCP) using Modelica and Optimization language specifications, and solve the underlying model formulation using a range of optimization methods, including direct collocation and direct multiple shooting.

### Compiling the Modelica code¶

Before exporting a model to XML, the model should be symbolically instantiated by the compiler in order to get a single flat system of equations. The model variables should also be scalarized. The compiler frontend performs this, including syntax checking, semantics and type checking, simplification and constant evaluation etc. are applied. Then the complete flattened model is exported to XML code. The exported XML document can then be imported to CasADi for model-based dynamic optimization.

The OpenModelica command translateModelXML(ModelName) from OMShell, OMNotebook or MDT exports the XML. The export XML command is also integrated with OMEdit. Select XML > Export XML the XML document is generated in the current directory of omc. You can use the cd() command to see the current location. After the command execution is complete you will see that a file ModelName.xml has been exported.

Assuming that the model is defined in the modelName.mo, the model can also be exported to an XML code using the following steps from the terminal window:

- Go to the path where your model file found
- Run command omc -g=Optimica --simCodeTarget=XML Model.mo

### An example¶

In this section, a simple optimal control problem will be solved. When formulating the optimization problems, models are expressed in the Modelica language and optimization specifications. The optimization language specification allows users to formulate dynamic optimization problems to be solved by a numerical algorithm. It includes several constructs including a new specialized class optimization, a constraint section, startTime, finalTime etc. See the optimal control problem for batch reactor model below.

Create a new file named BatchReactor.mo and save it in you working directory. Notice that this model contains both the dynamic system to be optimized and the optimization specification.

```
>>> list(BatchReactor)
model BatchReactor
Real x1(start = 1, fixed = true, min = 0, max = 1);
Real x2(start = 0, fixed = true, min = 0, max = 1);
input Real u(min = 0, max = 5);
equation
der(x1) = -(u + u ^ 2 / 2) * x1;
der(x2) = u * x1;
end BatchReactor;
```

One we have formulated the undelying optimal control problems, we can export the XML by using OMShell, OMNotebook, MDT, OMEdit or command line terminals which are described in Section XML Import to CasADi via OpenModelica Python Script.

To export XML, we set the simulation target to XML:

```
>>> translateModelXML(BatchReactor)
"«DOCHOME»/BatchReactor.xml"
```

This will generate an XML file named BatchReactor.xml (Listing 4) that contains a symbolic representation of the optimal control problem and can be inspected in a standard XML editor.

```
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<OpenModelicaModelDescription
xmlns:exp="https://svn.jmodelica.org/trunk/XML/daeExpressions.xsd"
xmlns:equ="https://svn.jmodelica.org/trunk/XML/daeEquations.xsd"
xmlns:fun="https://svn.jmodelica.org/trunk/XML/daeFunctions.xsd"
xmlns:opt="https://svn.jmodelica.org/trunk/XML/daeOptimization.xsd"
xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
fmiVersion="1.0"
modelName="BatchReactor"
modelIdentifier="BatchReactor"
guid="{f19a9e65-0cb4-4bb2-b40b-bffd3c8bb014}"
generationDateAndTime="2019-05-24T11:38:09"
variableNamingConvention="structured"
numberOfContinuousStates="2"
numberOfEventIndicators="0"
>
<VendorAnnotations>
<Tool name="OpenModelica Compiler OMCompiler v1.14.0-dev.268+gc33af0978"> </Tool>
</VendorAnnotations>
<ModelVariables>
<ScalarVariable name="x1" valueReference="0" variability="continuous" causality="internal" alias="noAlias">
<Real start="1.0" fixed="true" min="0.0" max="1.0" />
<QualifiedName>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x1"/>
</QualifiedName>
<isLinearTimedVariables>
<TimePoint index="0" isLinear="true"/>
</isLinearTimedVariables>
<VariableCategory>state</VariableCategory>
</ScalarVariable>
<ScalarVariable name="x2" valueReference="1" variability="continuous" causality="internal" alias="noAlias">
<Real start="0.0" fixed="true" min="0.0" max="1.0" />
<QualifiedName>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x2"/>
</QualifiedName>
<isLinearTimedVariables>
<TimePoint index="0" isLinear="true"/>
</isLinearTimedVariables>
<VariableCategory>state</VariableCategory>
</ScalarVariable>
<ScalarVariable name="der(x1)" valueReference="2" variability="continuous" causality="internal" alias="noAlias">
<Real />
<QualifiedName>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x1"/>
</QualifiedName>
<isLinearTimedVariables>
<TimePoint index="0" isLinear="true"/>
</isLinearTimedVariables>
<VariableCategory>derivative</VariableCategory>
</ScalarVariable>
<ScalarVariable name="der(x2)" valueReference="3" variability="continuous" causality="internal" alias="noAlias">
<Real />
<QualifiedName>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x2"/>
</QualifiedName>
<isLinearTimedVariables>
<TimePoint index="0" isLinear="true"/>
</isLinearTimedVariables>
<VariableCategory>derivative</VariableCategory>
</ScalarVariable>
<ScalarVariable name="u" valueReference="4" variability="continuous" causality="input" alias="noAlias">
<Real min="0.0" max="5.0" />
<QualifiedName>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="u"/>
</QualifiedName>
<isLinearTimedVariables>
<TimePoint index="0" isLinear="true"/>
</isLinearTimedVariables>
<VariableCategory>algebraic</VariableCategory>
</ScalarVariable>
</ModelVariables>
<equ:BindingEquations>
</equ:BindingEquations>
<equ:DynamicEquations>
<equ:Equation>
<exp:Sub>
<exp:Der>
<exp:Identifier>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x2"/>
</exp:Identifier>
</exp:Der>
<exp:Mul>
<exp:Identifier>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="u"/>
</exp:Identifier>
<exp:Identifier>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x1"/>
</exp:Identifier>
</exp:Mul>
</exp:Sub>
</equ:Equation>
<equ:Equation>
<exp:Sub>
<exp:Der>
<exp:Identifier>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x1"/>
</exp:Identifier>
</exp:Der>
<exp:Mul>
<exp:Sub>
<exp:Mul>
<exp:RealLiteral>-0.5</exp:RealLiteral>
<exp:Pow>
<exp:Identifier>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="u"/>
</exp:Identifier>
<exp:RealLiteral>2.0</exp:RealLiteral>
</exp:Pow>
</exp:Mul>
<exp:Identifier>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="u"/>
</exp:Identifier>
</exp:Sub>
<exp:Identifier>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x1"/>
</exp:Identifier>
</exp:Mul>
</exp:Sub>
</equ:Equation>
</equ:DynamicEquations>
<equ:InitialEquations>
<equ:Equation>
<exp:Sub>
<exp:Identifier>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x1"/>
</exp:Identifier>
<exp:RealLiteral>1.0</exp:RealLiteral>
</exp:Sub>
</equ:Equation>
<equ:Equation>
<exp:Sub>
<exp:Identifier>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x2"/>
</exp:Identifier>
<exp:RealLiteral>0.0</exp:RealLiteral>
</exp:Sub>
</equ:Equation>
<equ:Equation>
<exp:Sub>
<exp:Identifier>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x1"/>
</exp:Identifier>
<exp:Identifier>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="$START"/>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x1"/>
</exp:Identifier>
</exp:Sub>
</equ:Equation>
<equ:Equation>
<exp:Sub>
</exp:Sub>
</equ:Equation>
<equ:Equation>
<exp:Sub>
</exp:Sub>
</equ:Equation>
<equ:Equation>
<exp:Sub>
<exp:Identifier>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x2"/>
</exp:Identifier>
<exp:Identifier>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="$START"/>
<exp:QualifiedNamePart name="x2"/>
</exp:Identifier>
</exp:Sub>
</equ:Equation>
</equ:InitialEquations>
<fun:Algorithm>
</fun:Algorithm>
<fun:RecordsList>
</fun:RecordsList>
<fun:FunctionsList>
</fun:FunctionsList>
<opt:Optimization>
<opt:TimePoints>
<opt:TimePoint >
</opt:TimePoint>
</opt:TimePoints>
<opt:PathConstraints>
</opt:PathConstraints>
</opt:Optimization>
</OpenModelicaModelDescription>
```

### XML Import to CasADi via OpenModelica Python Script¶

The symbolic optimal control problem representation (or just model description) contained in BatchReactor.xml can be imported into CasADi in the form of the SymbolicOCP class via OpenModelica python script.

The SymbolicOCP class contains symbolic representation of the optimal control problem designed to be general and allow manipulation. For a more detailed description of this class and its functionalities, we refer to the API documentation of CasADi.

The following step compiles the model to an XML format, imports to CasADi and solves an optimization problem in windows PowerShell:

Create a new file named BatchReactor.mo and save it in you working directory.

E.g. C:\OpenModelica1.9.2\share\casadi\testmodel

Perform compilation and generate the XML file

- Go to your working directory

E.g. cd C:\OpenModelica1.9.2\share\casadi\testmodel

Go to omc path from working directory and run the following command

E.g. ..\..\..\bin\omc +s -g=Optimica --simCodeTarget=XML BatchReactor.mo

3. Run defaultStart.py python script from OpenModelica optimization directory

E.g. Python.exe ..\share\casadi\scripts defaultStart.py BatchReactor.xml

The control and state trajectories of the optimization results are shown below:

## Parameter Sweep Optimization using OMOptim¶

OMOptim is a tool for parameter sweep design optimization of Modelica models. By optimization, one should understand a procedure which minimizes/maximizes one or more objective functions by adjusting one or more parameters. This is done by the optimization algorithm performing a parameter swep, i.e., systematically adjusting values of selected parameters and running a number of simulations for different parameter combinations to find a parameter setting that gives an optimal value of the goal function.

OMOptim 0.9 contains meta-heuristic optimization algorithms which allow optimizing all sorts of models with following functionalities:

- One or several objectives optimized simultaneously
- One or several parameters (integer or real variables)

However, the user must be aware of the large number of simulations an optimization might require.

### Preparing the Model¶

Before launching OMOptim, one must prepare the model in order to optimize it.

#### Parameters¶

An optimization parameter is picked up from all model variables. The choice of parameters can be done using the OMOptim interface.

For all intended parameters, please note that:

- The corresponding variable is
**constant**during all simulations. - The OMOptim optimization in version 0.9 only concerns static
parameters’ optimization
*i.e.*values found for these parameters will be constant during all simulation time.

- The corresponding variable is
- The corresponding variable should play an
**input**role in the model *i.e.*its modification influences model simulation results.

- The corresponding variable should play an

#### Constraints¶

If some constraints should be respected during optimization, they must be defined in the Modelica model itself.

For instance, if mechanical stress must be less than 5 N.m^{-2},
one should write in the model:

```
assert(mechanicalStress < 5, "Mechanical stress too high");
```

If during simulation, the variable *mechanicalStress* exceeds 5
N.m^{-2}, the simulation will stop and be considered as a failure.

#### Objectives¶

As parameters, objectives are picked up from model variables.
Objectives’ values are considered by the optimizer at the *final time*.

### Set problem in OMOptim¶

#### Launch OMOptim¶

OMOptim can be launched using the executable placed in OpenModelicaInstallationDirectory/bin/ OMOptim/OMOptim.exe. Alternately, choose OpenModelica > OMOptim from the start menu.

#### Create a new project¶

To create a new project, click on menu File -> New project

Then set a name to the project and save it in a dedicated folder. The created file created has a .min extension. It will contain information regarding model, problems, and results loaded.

#### Load models¶

First, you need to load the model(s) you want to optimize. To do so,
click on *Add .mo* button on main window or select menu *Model -> Load
Mo file…*

When selecting a model, the file will be loaded in OpenModelica which runs in the background.

While OpenModelica is loading the model, you could have a frozen interface. This is due to multi-threading limitation but the delay should be short (few seconds).

You can load as many models as you want.

If an error occurs (indicated in log window), this might be because:

- Dependencies have not been loaded before (e.g. modelica library)
- Model use syntax incompatible with OpenModelica.

**Dependencies**

OMOptim should detect dependencies and load corresponding files. However, it some errors occur, please load by yourself dependencies. You can also load Modelica library using Model->Load Modelica library.

When the model correctly loaded, you should see a window similar to Figure 73.

#### Create a new optimization problem¶

Problem->Add Problem->Optimization

A dialog should appear. Select the model you want to optimize. Only Model can be selected (no Package, Component, Block…).

A new form will be displayed. This form has two tabs. One is called Variables, the other is called Optimization.

**List of Variables is Empty**

If variables are not displayed, right click on model name in model
hierarchy, and select *Read variables*.

#### Select Optimized Variables¶

To set optimization, we first have to define the variables the optimizer
will consider as free *i.e.* those that it should find best values of.
To do this, select in the left list, the variables concerned. Then, add
them to *Optimized variables* by clicking on corresponding button
().

For each variable, you must set minimum and maximum values it can take.
This can be done in the *Optimized variables* table.

#### Select objectives¶

Objectives correspond to the final values of chosen variables. To select
these last, select in left list variables concerned and click
button of *Optimization objectives* table.

For each objective, you must:

- Set minimum and maximum values it can take. If a configuration does
- not respect these values, this configuration won’t be considered. You also can set minimum and maximum equals to “-“ : it will then

- Define whether objective should be minimized or maximized.

This can be done in the *Optimized variables* table.

#### Select and configure algorithm¶

After having selected variables and objectives, you should now select
and configure optimization algorithm. To do this, click on
*Optimization* tab.

Here, you can select optimization algorithm you want to use. In version 0.9, OMOptim offers three different genetic algorithms. Let’s for example choose SPEA2Adapt which is an auto-adaptative genetic algorithm.

By clicking on *parameters*… button, a dialog is opened allowing
defining parameters. These are:

*Population size*: this is the number of configurations kept after a- generation. If it is set to 50, your final result can’t contain more than 50 different points.

*Off spring rate*: this is the number of children per adult obtained- after combination process. If it is set to 3, each generation will contain 150 individual (considering population size is 50).

*Max generations*: this number defines the number of generations- after which optimization should stop. In our case, each
generation corresponds to 150 simulations. Note that you can
still stop optimization while it is running by clicking on
*stop*button (which will appear once optimization is launched). Therefore, you can set a really high number and still stop optimization when you want without losing results obtained until there.

*Save frequency*: during optimization, best configurations can be- regularly saved. It allows to analyze evolution of best
configurations but also to restart an optimization from
previously obtained results. A Save Frequency parameter set to 3
means that after three generations, a file is automatically
created containing best configurations. These files are named
iteraion1.sav, iteration2.sav and are store in
*Temp*directory, and moved to*SolvedProblems*directory when optimization is finished.

*ReinitStdDev*: this is a specific parameter of EAAdapt1. It defines- whether standard deviation of variables should be reinitialized.
It is used only if you start optimization from previously
obtained configurations (using
*Use start file*option). Setting it to yes (1) will, in most of cases, lead to a spread research of optimized configurations, forgetting parameters’ variations’ reduction obtained in previous optimization.

**Use start file**

As indicated before, it is possible to pursue an optimization finished
or stopped. To do this, you must enable *Use start file* option and
select file from which optimization should be started. This file is an
*iteration_.sav* file created in previous optimization. It is stored in
corresponding *SolvedProblems* folder (*iteration10.sav* corresponds to
the tenth generation of previous optimization).

***Note that this functionality can only work with same variables and
objectives*.** However, minimum, maximum of variables and objectives can
be changed before pursuing an optimization.

#### Launch¶

You can now launch Optimization by clicking *Launch* button.

#### Stopping Optimization¶

Optimization will be stopped when the generation counter will reach the
generation number defined in parameters. However, you can still stop the
optimization while it is running without loosing obtained results. To do
this, click on *Stop* button. Note that this will not immediately stop
optimization: it will first finish the current generation.

This stop function is especially useful when optimum points do not vary any more between generations. This can be easily observed since at each generation, the optimum objectives values and corresponding parameters are displayed in log window.

### Results¶

The result tab appear when the optimization is finished. It consists of two parts: a table where variables are displayed and a plot region.

#### Obtaining all Variable Values¶

During optimization, the values of optimized variables and objectives
are memorized. The others are not. To get these last, you must
recomputed corresponding points. To achieve this, select one or several
points in point’s list region and click on *recompute*.

For each point, it will simulate model setting input parameters to point corresponding values. All values of this point (including those which are not optimization parameters neither objectives).

### Window Regions in OMOptim GUI¶

[BOR+12] | Bernhard Bachmann, Lennart Ochel, Vitalij Ruge, Mahder Gebremedhin, Peter Fritzson, Vaheed Nezhadali, Lars Eriksson, and Martin Sivertsson. Parallel multiple-shooting and collocation Optimization with OpenModelica. In Martin Otter and Dirk Zimmer, editors, Proceedings of the 9th International Modelica Conference. Linköping University Electronic Press, September 2012. doi:10.3384/ecp12076659. |

[RBB+14] | Vitalij Ruge, Willi Braun, Bernhard Bachmann, Andrea Walther, and Kshitij Kulshreshtha. Efficient implementation of collocation methods for optimization using openmodelica and adol-c. In Hubertus Tummescheit and Karl-Erik Årzén, editors, Proceedings of the 10th International Modelica Conference. Modelica Association and Linköping University Electronic Press, March 2014. doi:10.3384/ecp140961017. |